Total closure for permutation actions of finite nonabelian simple groups

Saul D. Freedman, Michael Giudici, Cheryl Praeger

Published 2022-06-06Version 1

For a positive integer $k$, a group $G$ is said to be totally $k$-closed if for each set $\Omega$ upon which $G$ acts faithfully, $G$ is the largest subgroup of $\mathrm{Sym}(\Omega)$ that leaves invariant each of the $G$-orbits in the induced action on $\Omega\times\cdots\times \Omega=\Omega^k$. Each finite group $G$ is totally $|G|$-closed, and $k(G)$ denotes the least integer $k$ such that $G$ is totally $k$-closed. We address the question of determining the closure number $k(G)$ for finite simple groups $G$. Prior to our work it was known that $k(G)=2$ for cyclic groups of prime order and for precisely six of the sporadic simple groups, and that $k(G)\geq3$ for all other finite simple groups. We determine the value for the alternating groups, namely $k(A_n)=n-1$. In addition, for all simple groups $G$, other than alternating groups and classical groups, we show that $k(G)\leq 7$. Finally, if $G$ is a finite simple classical group with natural module of dimension $n$, we show that $k(G)\leq n+2$ if $n \ge 14$, and $k(G) \le \lfloor n/3 + 12 \rfloor$ otherwise, with smaller bounds achieved by certain families of groups. This is achieved by determining a uniform upper bound (depending on $n$ and the type of $G$) on the base sizes of the primitive actions of $G$, based on known bounds for specific actions. We pose several open problems aimed at completing the determination of the closure numbers for finite simple groups.