arXiv Analytics

Sign in

arXiv:1911.02555 [quant-ph]AbstractReferencesReviewsResources

Interactive shallow Clifford circuits: quantum advantage against NC$^1$ and beyond

Daniel Grier, Luke Schaeffer

Published 2019-11-06Version 1

Recent work of Bravyi et al. and follow-up work by Bene Watts et al. demonstrates a quantum advantage for shallow circuits: constant-depth quantum circuits can perform a task which constant-depth classical (i.e., AC$^0$) circuits cannot. Their results have the advantage that the quantum circuit is fairly practical, and their proofs are free of hardness assumptions (e.g., factoring is classically hard, etc.). Unfortunately, constant-depth classical circuits are too weak to yield a convincing real-world demonstration of quantum advantage. We attempt to hold on to the advantages of the above results, while increasing the power of the classical model. Our main result is a two-round interactive task which is solved by a constant-depth quantum circuit (using only Clifford gates, between neighboring qubits of a 2D grid, with Pauli measurements), but such that any classical solution would necessarily solve $\oplus$L-hard problems. This implies a more powerful class of constant-depth classical circuits (e.g., AC$^0[p]$ for any prime $p$) unconditionally cannot perform the task. Furthermore, under standard complexity-theoretic conjectures, log-depth circuits and log-space Turing machines cannot perform the task either. Using the same techniques, we prove hardness results for weaker complexity classes under more restrictive circuit topologies. Specifically, we give QNC$^0$ interactive tasks on $2 \times n$ and $1 \times n$ grids which require classical simulations of power NC$^1$ and AC$^{0}[6]$, respectively. Moreover, these hardness results are robust to a small constant fraction of error in the classical simulation. We use ideas and techniques from the theory of branching programs, quantum contextuality, measurement-based quantum computation, and Kilian randomization.

Related articles: Most relevant | Search more
arXiv:2005.02607 [quant-ph] (Published 2020-05-06)
Towards quantum advantage for topological data analysis
arXiv:quant-ph/0511272 (Published 2005-11-30)
Quantum Advantage without Entanglement
arXiv:quant-ph/0507270 (Published 2005-07-28)
Quantum Minimal One Way Information: Relative Hardness and Quantum Advantage of Combinatorial Tasks